Should You Buy a Cast Iron or an Enameled Cast Iron Skillet?

Should You Buy a Cast Iron or an Enameled Cast Iron Skillet?

Should You Buy a Cast Iron or an Enameled Cast Iron Skillet?

A reliable skillet is a must-have in every kitchen. However, as you search for the perfect cooking companion, you may wonder whether to go for the classic strength of uncoated cast iron or the sleek modernity of its enameled counterpart.

This culinary dilemma is more than choosing a new cookware – it's an exploration between old and new. When comparing cast iron vs. enameled cast iron skillet, you'll realize that both options have distinct advantages and setbacks. So, which is the better one?

Below, we compare these two cooking contenders and explore their unique features and benefits. This way, you'll better understand how they differ from each other, allowing you to make informed decisions on your next purchase. 

Tighten your apron strings, and let's dive in!

What's the Difference?: Cast Iron vs. Enameled Cast Iron Skillet

When choosing between enamel vs. cast iron skillet, the decision depends on many factors. The two options may seem similar, but a closer examination reveals distinct characteristics.

So, let's break down the key differences between the enamel and cast iron skillets:

Composition and Coating

The main difference between a cast iron and an enameled cast iron skillet lies in the composition.

A classic cast iron skillet is made from a single piece of iron, which makes it great at retaining heat and can become nonstick with proper seasoning. On the other hand, an enameled cast iron skillet, like the ones offered by Larder & Vine, is coated with 3 layers of enamel – a glass-like substance that acts as a barrier between the cookware and food. The enamel also gives the skillet a smooth, non-reactive surface that doesn't need to be seasoned for nonstick performance.

Heat Conduction and Retention

Both skillets are great at keeping heat, making them perfect for cooking dishes that require even temperatures. However, the heat conductivity of cast iron skillets may be slightly lower compared to cast iron cookware with enamel coating.

The thickness of the outer layer influences the conductivity of an enameled cast iron skillet. However, it generally retains heat well and provides a more uniform distribution compared to its traditional counterpart.

Seasoning and Nonstick Properties

A cast iron skillet becomes seasoned when oil bonds to the iron through polymerization. This creates a nonstick surface that gets better with time and proper care. On the other hand, the coating on an enameled cast iron skillet provides immediate nonstick benefits but may show signs of wear as time passes. To maintain its performance, careful use is required.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Caring for a traditional cast iron skillet involves washing it with mild, soapy water, gently scrubbing to preserve seasoning, and then seasoning it with oil to maintain nonstick properties. Due to its coating, an enameled cast iron skillet offers easier post-cooking cleanup. They can be soaked, washed, and dried without regular seasoning, allowing you to save precious time and energy.

Aesthetics and Variety

Enameled cast iron cookware brings vibrant colors to the culinary stage, offering a visually appealing dimension that their seasoned versions can't match. While traditional cast iron skillets are known for their deep, rustic black hue that develops over time, enameled versions introduce a kaleidoscope of options to suit every kitchen's aesthetic. From bold reds to serene blues, cast iron cookware with enamel coating infuses a touch of personal style into your cooking space, enhancing its visual appeal and enabling seamless coordination with your kitchen decor.

Enamel vs. Cast Iron Skillet Budget Considerations

Regular cast iron skillets typically emerge as the more wallet-friendly option than the enameled variety. These sturdy cookware options offer great value for their price, often exceeding expectations and showcasing the enduring artistry of culinary craftsmanship.

On the other hand, a cast iron skillet with enamel coating comes with a slightly higher initial investment due to the added production cost and the meticulous quality control many brands uphold. However, it's essential to recognize that this upfront cost often translates into long-term benefits.

Enameled cast iron skillets are renowned for their ability to withstand wear and tear, which means you'll acquire a piece of cookware that can last for generations. Additionally, the convenience of the enamel coating, offering nonstick properties without the need for regular seasoning, saves a lot of effort in the kitchen.

A Tale of Two Skillets

After investigating the comparisons between cast iron and enameled cast iron skillets, it's clear that one is not better than the other. Both contenders boast their unique advantages.

The seasoned cast iron skillet stands as a symbol of culinary tradition, offering unparalleled heat retention and natural nonstick properties. On the other hand, the enameled cast iron skillet, clad in its glossy and vibrant coat, ushers in the modern era with its convenience, diverse aesthetics, and nonstick benefits straight out of the box.

When deciding which cooking tool to use, consider your culinary requirements and what is important to you. If you want to become an expert in maintaining cast iron, the traditional route may be the way to go. However, if you prefer a kitchen tool that's easy to use, requires little maintenance, and adds a pop of color to your space, then the enameled variation is the better option.

Explore Larder & Vine's Enameled Cookware Collection

If the allure of a cast iron skillet with enamel coating has captured your interest, look no further than Larder & Vine's exquisite collection of enameled cookware. Our curated selection showcases the perfect blend of form and function that is sure to fulfill every cooking need. Don’t hesitate to contact us for any questions.

Shop today!

Shop the story